Zoning Board of Appeals — November 12, 2026
0:07 Littleborough Zoning Board of Appeals to order.0:10 First item on our agenda is to announce that the meeting is being recorded per Mass General Laws Section 30A, Section 20F.0:19 Item 2 on the agenda, um, will be Michael O'Shaughnessy, Esquire, on behalf of Numascus Capital Partners LLC.0:27 Um, relative to, uh, 20— um, excuse me, LLC 10-16 and 22 School Street map, 50P lots 5365, 5363, and 5414.0:45 This hearing will be continued due to the fact that we do not have 5 members on the board at the, at the time.0:53 We should be getting an appointment on Monday, so we should be good to go.0:57 So this meeting will be continued till, uh, January 14th, 2027, due to the fact that we only have, um, one meeting in December.1:10 Um, so I will entertain a motion to continue.1:12 I will have to recuse myself from this one.1:15 Duly noted.1:17 Um, Do I have a motion?1:20 So moved.1:21 Second?1:22 Second.1:23 Motion made and seconded.1:24 Discussion on the motion?1:26 Hearing none, all those in favor?1:28 Aye.1:29 Aye.1:29 Carries unanimously.1:31 So if you're here for School Street, you can come back on January 14th, 2027.1:40 All right, next on the agenda, item 3, Michael O'Shaughnessy, Esquire, On behalf of NESPLLC, off of East Grove Street, Map 072, Lot 2616, request to be granted a special permit pursuant to Section 4.11, 453, 5313, and 921 to authorize the construction of a surf park, 3 buildings, several accessory structures and 35 cottages-style hotel motel units whose cumulative square footage would exceed 20,000 square feet.2:18 Subject property is located off East Grove Street, being a 20-plus acre parcel of land, being a portion of the lot shown in Middleborough's assessor's map 072, lot 2616, in the General Use B District.2:35 This hearing was continued from October 20 2nd, 2026.2:39 Declare the hearing open, and the floor is yours.2:41 Good evening.2:42 Good evening, Mr. Chairman and all members of the Zoning Board of Appeals.2:45 My name is Michael O'Shaughnessy.2:46 I'm here today on behalf of NESP LLC.2:50 With me today is, uh, Jerry Picillo.2:53 He's one of the principals of, uh, NESP LLC.2:57 I have Chris Tracy from O'Neill and Associates, uh, Keith Curran from Bowler, uh, he's our civil engineer, and, uh, Emily Sullivan from Bowman.3:05 She's our traffic person.3:08 Uh, the last time we were here, we had just received some comments from Apex, um, and we had, um, revised our plans accordingly.3:16 Um, and the last time you heard Mr. Stair say that we— it was his opinion that we were pretty close to wrapping up the civil side, but they had to finalize their letter.3:27 Uh, a letter was issued last week, November 3rd, 2020, 6 from Apex.3:32 If you go through the letter, you'll note that most of our— most of the comments, if not all the comments, have been addressed but for one.3:41 If you look on item 7 on page 5 of 24, we had a couple of our curbs having a radius of 10 feet.3:50 Apex wanted them switched to 15 feet.3:53 Um, that's what the bylaw required.3:56 Um, that, that's an easy change for us.4:00 Um, but with respect to the civil side of things, but for that one change, we're, we're effectively done.4:10 Uh, if you also recall, the last time we were here, um, we were in the process of meeting with MassDOT to discuss some of our traffic issues.4:21 So there was a couple of meetings with, with MassDOT.4:24 We met with David Mohler, Jonathan Gulliver, Jacob Hardaway, and Lionel Lucien.4:30 Some of those folks are from Boston and some of those folks are from the Taunton office.4:34 What we had discussed with them is how do we approach this project by way of design?4:41 Because let's face it, this is a unique project.4:44 There aren't a whole lot of these.4:47 So what we did is we presented some information to them regarding trip generation, traffic projection, and some supporting analysis for it, just to make sure they were on board with our approach.5:01 And I'll let Emily discuss this more in a minute.5:07 So basically, those folks were comfortable with our approach.5:13 I asked them if they could give us something in writing, and of course they're not going to give us anything in writing.5:18 At this time.5:18 Their response was our comments will be provided through you— to you through the MEPA process.5:24 And that's fine.5:27 So— when do they expect to generate that?5:30 Oh, that won't be till— that won't be till April, May when we get their comments.5:35 Well, then enlighten us on the process as far as what your intention is.5:40 Well, so part of the issue— and it has to do with mitigation.5:45 Yeah, and I think what I'd like to do is— there's several options floating out there.5:50 Do you want to explain it first?5:52 Do you want to do the traffic study first?5:54 I think, I think it makes sense to have— because Bowman's addressed a lot of that.5:58 Yep.5:58 In their letter.5:59 So it probably makes more sense to have Emily come, um, talk.6:04 Well, I just don't want to have people confused if we're going to have to throw your ideas out first and then we'll have to mesh it with the traffic study.6:10 So if we do the study first, then we can at least understand.6:13 Yep, absolutely.6:14 Or at least have a basic baseline to work from.6:19 Good evening.6:20 Hello, Emily Sullivan with Bowman.6:24 So as was, you know, mentioned, we, we've addressed the peer review comments received by Apex.6:29 We provided responses a couple weeks ago on the 6th.6:33 So a lot of the comments were just providing clarification information or additional background calculations that we provided, and then As was mentioned, one of the notable comments, which was also brought up by MassDOT, was regarding the trip generation, since this is a unique use.6:49 And also, as was mentioned, you know, we met with MassDOT a couple times and really worked with them to settle on an approach that they were comfortable with in terms of the trip generation.7:00 So what we did is, you know, there's multiple amenities on site, and, you know, layering on top of the data provided by Wavegarden, just layering the trip estimates associated with those amenities, taking a conservative approach in adding those together rather than taking into account in reality people would go and kind of in one trip share those amenities during their time at the site.7:25 So MassDOT was comfortable with that approach.7:28 As was mentioned, still will be— as we provided updated analysis reflective of that in our responses to Apex.7:36 And we'll provide that same information and analysis to MassDOT as part of the MEPA process, which they'll comment on at that time.7:45 So based on that updated and conservative approach, we reran our analysis presented in the study and found overall similar findings and conclusions, minimal impacts to the study area intersections, and no impacts to Route 28, the through traffic on Route 28.8:03 28 at the site driveway.8:10 All right, so do we want to walk through some of the conclusions based on the traffic study, um, what the recommendations were as far as is it going to be mitigation, we're going to do turning lanes, are we going to— so the, um, again, the mitigation will continue to be worked out with MassDOT.8:29 Right now what we're looking at, um, There's a road safety audit that was completed at the Cherry Street intersection, which is shown to have existing high crash rate and, you know, of the intersections we analyzed, you know, on the poorer side of operations.8:43 So looking at the recommendations from that road safety audit and looking at what, you know, makes sense in scale of the project to improve there.8:52 So we're looking at some of the recommendations from that report and we'll be submitting that to MassDOT as well as part of the MEPA process.8:59 That was again one of their comments, you know, asking about mitigation.9:02 So that will certainly be, you know, something that they'll be reviewing and requiring as well.9:14 Anybody have a question?9:17 Good.9:18 No, go ahead.9:19 All right.9:20 So can you walk us through the trip generation estimates?9:24 Sure.9:25 Yeah, I'm up there now.9:26 Just walk us through what it means, what it's saying.9:29 Yeah, of course.9:30 So the 3 rows, starting with the surf park trips, that, that top row is based on the data present provided by Wave Garden.9:38 Again, those, you know, are likely to include, you know, some credit for the amenities, you know, people who are going and using the other amenities on site.9:49 But since each surf park is a little bit different, you know, in our discussions with MassDOT, they were more comfortable if we didn't kind of group it all together and just separated them out.9:58 So the 2 rows following that, the cottage trips are associated with the cottages.10:04 So that's based on ITE trip gen data, more standard practice for a traffic study.10:10 And then layered again on top of that, the restaurant trips.10:14 So again, likely to be shared trips between those uses, but we did not take any credit for internal capture and people using those different sites in one trip, we've added them together to kind of take a conservative approach overall, which is what MassDOT was most comfortable with.10:33 So the total number of 2,283 is the daily trips.10:40 That's daily ins and outs.10:43 Yes.10:43 Right.10:43 Total.10:43 Yep.10:44 And then going right from there, the weekday afternoon peak hour and then the Saturday midday peak hour.10:49 And for each of those, entering, exiting, and total is summarized.10:55 So again, the weekday total, weekday daily total, that's, that's a 24-hour number, correct?11:02 Okay.11:11 Okay, just wanted to make sure we had that.11:29 All right, so based on those kind of numbers that we're looking at, Did you come up with a plan as far as what you're going to do with traffic in terms of— well, you've got— you'll have left-hand turns coming in off of the major access from 495.11:57 You're going to have traffic coming from either side.11:59 Now, if you're coming from the Cherry Street side, there's, there's way more room to queue up turning traffic than they would be going the other way because you got Wareham Street that comes in, which is significantly close to where you're going to put the entrance.12:14 Sure.12:14 I don't know if, if there's going to have to be design changes to Wareham Street, which is probably something we should have done at some point, but, um, I just don't know if that's going to enter into the calculus of this project, because if you're queuing up people enough to back traffic up that far, you're going to have to deal with the intersection.12:34 That's my point.12:35 Uh, yeah, so we did analyze, you know, at the site driveway, both, um, you know, the stop control approach at the actual driveway and Route 28 as well.12:43 And there's really minimal queuing, uh, you know, just somebody waiting to turn left into the site.12:48 We certainly don't see that queue extend to Wareham Street.12:52 Uh, and Wareham Street— yeah, so looking at, you know, the, the total trips in an hour, that's distributed through the network, so they're not all coming from one direction.13:01 Um, I get that.13:03 I just— I'm just curious.13:07 Given the volume, I would think that there would be more mitigation that would have to be done.13:12 We did run warrants for turn lanes.13:15 And there are volume thresholds that MassDOT requires to include a turn lane.13:20 And we're not— we do not meet those warrants for a turn lane at the driveway.13:32 Interesting.13:32 So the hours of operation for the Wave Park, again, if you can remind me, what were those going to be?13:40 You have the hours of operation exactly?13:43 Uh, I— we haven't solidified it right now, but it's probably 8 in the morning till like 10 at night, and that would be the, the surf park itself, and maybe the restaurant would go, you know, longer.13:59 I think the restaurants are going to run back and forth, right?14:02 They're going to do— yeah.14:03 Um, okay.14:12 I'm just trying to come up with how many trips per hour within the time frame.14:19 Did you do any math on that?14:20 So we analyzed, you know, looking at the peak hours, kind of worst-case scenario, again, with a use like this, that's the afternoon and a Saturday.14:31 Apex did have a comment asking about the weekday morning peak hour, but the weekday morning is, you know, a much lower generator at the site as it's, you know, mostly people entering and then they're there for a long period of time and exiting, you know, throughout the day.14:45 So the afternoon and the Saturday kind of reflect Um, you know, the peak of ins and ins and outs to the site.14:51 Okay, but roughly 14 hours of operation, am I correct?14:56 All right, and then, you know, obviously you're going to have workers coming in before that and workers after, so maybe extend that to 16 hours.15:14 So even if we just took the surf park itself, not with any of the others— well, we might as well do them all because they're all together.15:23 It's easier to do.15:39 So how many are you coming out with roughly in your— I mean, you do this all the time.15:44 So how many trips per hour or per minute?15:47 Per minute.15:49 So during peak hour or just, you know, any hour?15:52 That 16 hours we were talking about.15:56 I mean, we haven't broken it down by minute.15:58 We really focus on the peak hours for our— No, I know, but Peak hours are just— we want— if you looked at the whole thing, because people are coming in and out before it opens and after it closes, obviously, you know, cleaning up.16:14 So if you took the, the 2,283 and divided it by 16 and then divided it by 60, you're getting about 2.4 Trips a minute.16:30 Is that per minute?16:31 Per minute.16:32 Does that make sense?16:33 Was that number, um, unreasonable with the number?16:35 I think that, you know, that, that makes sense.16:37 I mean, looking at the peak hour, it's 190, um, you know, during the peak.16:42 So that's, you know, obviously over 2 a minute.16:44 So, um, I think that makes sense.16:48 Yeah.16:49 Okay.16:49 So now we have regular, right?16:53 And that's— this is additional to This is added traffic.17:02 Okay, so coming from Wayham Street, you need to turn the left.17:12 Um, do you usually have some type of calculation that would say what would be the expected wait time for someone to turn left?17:21 Based on the traffic that's already on 28?17:25 Yes, so we did include that in our analysis, uh, for the traffic study.17:29 You know, we— like I said, we did look at the through traffic.17:33 Um, let's see, usually we focus on, you know, the critical stop-controlled approaches.17:39 Those are usually the worst, um, in terms of delay.17:42 Um, so it might be in a back appendix page, um, a little harder to find.17:48 I know this, it's It's pretty deep.17:50 I realize that.17:52 Um, and I realize when someone's coming from the other direction, they're turning right, they don't have to wait for anybody.18:03 It's really coming in blocking 28.18:08 That's what I'm talking about.18:10 Because even when they're leaving, that's queuing up onto the new road back.18:14 So that's not Blocking 28.18:16 So in the attachments, it is going to be in the— it's the last attachment, which I don't have a printed copy of, but I can print it out if we're able to scroll down.18:27 Right there.18:27 Perfect.18:30 So looking at the— it's the last one here.18:33 So I'm going to come over here.18:36 There's a point.18:38 Oh, there's a point.18:39 Thank you.18:41 Not the walk across.18:42 OK, so this westbound left through, so it's a shared lane.18:47 So that's why it's grouped together.18:50 So we're seeing level of service A, you know, a second of delay.18:55 And again, like you said, coming from the other direction, people aren't going to have to wait to turn right.18:59 So that's why above that, for that movement, you see zero.19:02 So you can see it is a little bit of an increase from, you know, a nothing delay, but still, you know, 1 second of average delay.19:12 Um, so you're— so this is assuming that there's going to be periods of time where there's no traffic, they pull up to that?19:20 Correct, yes.19:21 This is an average vehicle, um, you know, during the peak hour.19:24 So, um, you know, sure, some people might wait a little bit longer than that, but that's an average, um, for the number of vehicles over the course of the hour.19:32 And then This last number is the queue in feet.19:36 So it's less than one vehicle queued on average.19:39 I know the question was raised if, if it would impact Wareham Street.19:42 So certainly not reaching close to Wareham Street.19:48 So the queue, where is that?19:50 That's one.19:52 So reading right, left to right from the 2033 build revised, Level of Service A, 1.4 seconds of average delay.20:03 The number after that is the capacity, volume to capacity, just showing that it's far under capacity.20:09 Usually for an uncontrolled movement, you don't see any capacity issues.20:14 And then the queue is the last number, the 5, and that's in feet.20:18 So less than one vehicle of— or, you know, obviously we're not going to say it's— all right, so 5 is half of a vehicle, so we'll say one.20:26 All right, that's what I didn't know— feet.20:28 All right, so based on the amount of coming and goings and coming that way and the traffic coming the other way, that would slow it down to turn.20:52 I see the 5, so that's how you come up to the 5 feet.20:56 Okay.20:57 All right, thank you.21:07 Any other questions from the board?21:11 Um, Mr.21:11 Chair, just reading in the report here, you're talking about bicycle storage for employees and I know, um, the state was discussing bicycle lanes.21:24 Is that something that you're going to be going forward with in your plan?21:28 Um, not on Route 28.21:31 Um, yeah, but in the site itself, um, I'm not sure exactly what the, the roadway width— I know that, you know, we're providing the 2 turn lanes.21:39 I'm not sure the use of the other roadway width in the site internal site roadway itself.21:45 I don't know if that's shown on on the site plans at this time, at this level, but I don't know if Oler wants to speak to that more.21:58 Is our engineer here?22:01 Yes.22:01 So we we already have that subdivision approval to kind of subdivide for the road coming off at 28, and there's no bike lane.22:08 Okay, on that, no, no internal bike lane.22:11 Thank you.22:12 No, I was just reading in here where it was just stating that on— so when it says on-site bicycle racks will be installed to promote bicycle use by employees, that's just within the development, not out?22:24 Correct.22:24 Yeah.22:25 Okay, thank you.22:38 So as of right now, the way it's with the state, the road— nothing so far is being proposed to change on the road, correct?22:50 28, right?22:50 So there's— there isn't, as of right now, a lane to turn in, correct?22:55 And there isn't a lane to go around the people trying to turn in left.23:00 Correct.23:01 OK. All right.23:04 But that would be up to the DOT anyway, right?23:07 And we did run those warrants.23:08 The volume warrants are not met for an exclusive turn lane into the site.23:13 So typically, MassDOT wants to see those— a demand to be identified to meet those warrants in order for that to be proposed.23:24 OK.23:29 So moving forward with the development, because there's a road that's been approved to be put in there, typically you would build off of this.23:41 Whoever comes in the next time would build off of your study, or would they build off of actual— would they do a study on site?23:51 So they would take— if, you know, similar to how we've included, you know, we call them background projects.23:57 So any projects that has been locally approved, they would need to incorporate trip projections based on that into their study.24:07 If it's something that's already been built, then obviously they can do traffic counts and not base it off projections.24:13 They can actually, you know, based on actual data reflective of that development.24:17 On the roadway.24:21 Okay, those are my questions.24:37 Okay, Nancy?24:39 Um, none.24:40 Yeah, the only question I actually had, and it goes with the bicycle goals is, um, I believe there was something— I believe SERPED has done a study to put bike lanes along Route 28.24:55 Did we, uh, did— was that taken into consideration?25:00 So we did, uh, look into— similar to the background projects, we look at any roadway improvement projects that are happening that would impact, you know, patterns or whatnot.25:10 And that was not identified as one at the time.25:12 It usually depends on how far along they are in the design and, and how, you know, how far along that project is, whether or not it's something they would recommend us to include.25:24 So that was not one that was mentioned.25:35 I know it's been heavily discussed.25:41 I know it's been heavily discussed with SERPAD.25:44 I thought I read it in here somewhere.25:45 I was just looking for it, but okay, I'll find it.26:10 Thank you.26:10 I just want to make sure.26:13 Okay, good.26:13 You got good?26:14 Okay, I'm good.26:15 Very good, Mr. Shonsey.26:20 Um, that's all we have, Mr. Chairman.26:24 Um, Again, part of the discussions with MassDOT is, as I said earlier, they're going to provide their comments to the MEPA process.26:38 And one of the comments to our team was that they're going to monitor the traffic afterwards as well.26:43 So it's— they're not saying, you guys go ahead and we're going to forget about it.26:53 Well, I guess my feeling on that subject would be it'd be better to address it now than later, but I don't have the ability to foresee the future.27:14 So a project like this.27:16 That is being developed, who would be the oversight on this?27:24 Or is there any oversight on this?27:26 A third party, that's what I mean.27:28 For our project, Joe?27:30 For your— well, for the way all the storm drainage, all that type of thing.27:34 Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh.27:36 Um, my, my guess is, well, they'll the property owners will do something similar to what we did at Campus 44.27:48 So we'll bring in a third party?27:50 Well, no, it would be a trust would— I would guess a trust would assess.27:58 It would be the trust and the occupants of the roadway, whoever that may be, will all put money into a fund and take care of the maintenance of the roadway and the stormwater basins and all that kind of stuff.28:12 And then what about during construction?28:15 I think using Campus 44, I think we had a third party that came in to do oversight during the construction, uh, for the town.28:24 Yes, just so— not the structure because that's under the building department, but stormwater or any other kind of drainage, all the things that we went through, that'll be on the plans.28:37 So, so I would imagine that, um, it'll be similar to what we did down there.28:41 We'd have the initial site meetings, um, our engineers— we owe you an as-built.28:48 If this board or a designee of the board wanted to come down and do inspections or visit, that's fine.28:56 Are you open to a third party coming down during construction Um, not where we typically do it on a roadway construction, because that, that's separate from that, because the roadway construction is, is planning.29:11 But someone that just makes sure that the drainage basins are being built to spec, not— so we don't have it.29:17 Well, again, if you're, if you're asking for Mr. Carrera to be that person, I, I, I— that would be nice.29:23 That'd be fine.29:24 I mean, I, I'd imagine that's who they'd the town would have.29:27 So the way this is going to go is construction on the surf park would go on at the same time as construction of the roadway.29:34 So I'd imagine that someone will be there from the town anyways.29:38 And if, if, if, if this board decides that you want someone to inspect the basins, I have no issue with that.29:44 Yeah, I would think we'd want to just make sure that everything is— that's right.29:48 Yeah, I have no problem with that.29:50 All right.29:52 So there might have to be a small fund that's put in for that.29:55 Yeah, they'll— they will provide a quote for that, I'm sure.29:59 It is what it is.30:06 So in this case, I guess whomever it is that's doing the roadway, if it is PMP, then— or whomever it is, whoever it is, right?30:14 Yeah.30:24 I have a question, but anyone can answer it.30:27 I think Mike would know because I've never heard of it.30:31 What is a transportation demand management coordinator and what would they do?30:39 I can't answer that.30:40 Emily, could you answer that?30:42 I have to learn something.30:44 Sure.30:45 So it's usually somebody designated on the site, an employee that is in charge of posting bus schedules, you know, making sure the bike racks are usable, you know, coordinating rideshare or carpool amongst employees and things like that.31:01 So it's just kind of the point person to, you know, look at transportation demand management strategies and make sure they're being implemented.31:10 Thank you.31:15 Now we both know, Mike.31:16 What's that?31:17 Now we both know.31:27 Okay, so I guess the other thing is— are we— oh, go ahead.31:30 Not on traffic.31:31 Are we done with— you want to finish?31:33 Well, we're going to finish traffic.31:35 Finished traffic?31:36 No, I'm done with traffic.31:37 Okay, if anybody else— who's running this meeting?31:45 Is there anyone in the audience who had a question on the traffic before we move on?31:56 Kristen Tebow, Blackfork Path.31:58 So does this study satisfy, satisfy your PERI requirement for the— for the traffic study.32:06 Yeah, thank you.32:19 Steve Spataro, 24 School Street.32:21 I wanted to thank the people for answering the question that I had last time.32:25 Guy Clearly was here for School Street.32:28 But I found this an intriguing project, and thank you for answering it.32:32 Uh, I have no objections to it, but I was trying to follow what you were presenting, so, uh, I just wanted a clarification because there might be other people watching that had a similar question.32:43 The weekly daily total of 2,000, is that a total for Monday through Friday, or is that Monday's total, the average of Monday Is that a daily total?32:55 Yes, one day.32:56 One day is the 2,000.32:58 Okay.32:59 Um, whether it's Canobie Lake Park, Disney, or some other, uh, entertainment venues, sometimes they have, uh, be in by 10, you know, uh, and stay all day.33:12 Uh, are there going to be any type of business practices that, uh, would skew when people want to get there?33:19 Or want to leave, and would those have been taken into account when you say that this is a maximum total in a specific hour time period?33:29 No.33:29 So you just have to come to the microphone, please.33:32 Thank you.33:33 Sorry.33:34 Uh, no.33:35 So that's just, um, you know, typical standard operations.33:39 Um, again, looking at kind of a conservative approach, but, uh, just a normal typical vehicle a weekday, not any special event or deal.33:49 Okay, so, um, do you— to the people proposing the project, are they expecting to do any type of, uh— it doesn't have to be an event, it's just, uh, standard business practice.34:04 Any other theme parks that you go to, they have, uh, in-buy and, you know, some type of attempt to get people there earlier.34:12 Does spend more money or those type of things.34:15 And so again, I was just curious if there were an intent to have any of those type of things that would skew the numbers that you have, which might impact what these folks are thinking about.34:25 I'm not aware of any.34:27 I just— I'd only like to clarify, it's not a theme park in the, in the, in the essence that you're going to have potentially thousands of people people there in the course of a day.34:41 Maybe I'm using the wrong term.34:43 Okay, well, I just— I don't want people at home to get the wrong idea of what we're putting in.34:47 Um, it's a surf park.34:49 It's specifically tied to surfing.34:52 So it's, it's not, it's not a place where you're going to come and drop your kids off, you know, 15, 20 kids off.34:59 It's all— it's strictly surfing.35:02 And from my understanding, with the exception of— I'm sure there's going to be some pool feature for the people who have, um, the cottages or cabanas or whatever.35:11 I'm sure there must— there's going to be some kind of function for that as well.35:15 But on the whole, I don't know, I just— I, I got the wrong impression the way you said it to me, and it just— it's kind of stuck.35:22 Well, restaurants, uh, yep, there'll be restaurants.35:24 Yeah, there were, there were different line items there.35:26 Yep.35:27 So again, I— some of them have been removed since the last hearing, like the yoga studio and that type of stuff they— this isn't Disney World.35:34 I, I understand that, but I just— well, when you say that, you, you conjure up a vision.35:39 Well, if it's, if it's great, I would expect some other kids in town to say, I want to take up surfing.35:46 And I— no, no, I'm sure we would like to encourage as many people as possible to come and partake.35:51 Absolutely.35:51 Yeah.35:52 And so I was just curious if there was any type of business practice to increase revenue.35:58 Uh, well, and they're free to answer the question.36:00 So I was just wondering if that was taken into the traffic, where there would be a couple of hours where there would be significantly more and it trickles off.36:08 That was on my own.36:09 Sure.36:09 And again, I'm not— I'm not objecting to this project.36:12 No, no, I was just curious.36:13 Thank you.36:14 Yeah, I didn't want to leave it hanging out there, that's all.36:17 We're not— we're not planning any come in before 10 and stay all day.36:21 Okay.36:22 I think we have 60 surface, and that could be in the pool at any one time.36:26 Well, that's what I mean.36:26 There's a limit to what you can accomplish.36:29 Yeah, I think it's going to be more like a golf course.36:31 You book your tee time and you show up for your hour or two, then you go away.36:34 So I don't think there's going to be mad rush, and it's, it's not going to be like a ski mountain where everyone shows up at once and everyone leaves at the end.36:41 Yeah, exactly.36:43 And the influx would be significant.36:48 I have another question.36:49 Sure.36:50 It's actually 2-part.36:52 So how many employees are you guys thinking you're going to have roughly?36:57 Uh, I think right now we're about 100.37:02 About 100?37:02 Yeah, full-time, part-time, it'll be a mix.37:06 It'll be slowly built up over time.37:08 Sure.37:09 All right, and you said you have a 14-hour day, so how many shifts do you think there would be and what time would the shifts be, and how would that affect the traffic?37:22 Um, I, I can't answer how many shifts they're going to be, Nancy, but, um, that's all built into our, our traffic study.37:28 Is that a safe statement, Emily?37:31 So those land uses, they do account for employees.37:35 Um, so it's, uh, you know, speaking to the, the ones that are based on ITE, so the, um, the cottage trips and the restaurant trips, those are collected at other similar land uses, so that includes employees associated with those sites.37:50 At certain times?37:50 So just say, you know, say you have mother's hours, you have— so like anything I've noticed said midday, which I was like, whatever.38:00 Midday was 11 to 12, and I'm like, midday?38:02 That's when you wake up, you know, 11 to 12 on a Saturday sometimes.38:07 But You know, it just didn't seem like it was midday.38:10 So then I started thinking about when I was working, you know, like I did construction, so we would have shifts.38:18 You know, you have the 3, you end at 3, you end at 11, you do the overnight.38:22 I know you guys won't be doing overnight, but so I'm trying to picture if we captured the traffic at those times, you know, because then you're talking maybe 30 people will be leaving at the same time and maybe 30 more will be coming in.38:33 I don't know.38:35 Yeah, so the, um, you know, any employees would be baked into those numbers.38:39 The midday might be a little misleading.38:42 Um, it's, it's labeled as midday.38:44 It doesn't really mean, you know, noon on a Saturday.38:47 Uh, it's the peak of, you know, I, I like that, after early afternoon.38:54 It's not like the 4 to 5 PM afternoon peak or the, you know, 7 to 9 AM morning peak.39:01 So it's, you know, doesn't mean right at noon.39:04 It could be like a 2 to 3 window.39:05 So it's just the peak hour of those trip generators.39:09 All right.39:09 Thank you.39:12 And actually, before you leave, I just want— so everyone listening, when you— when that first column, weekday, the total trips— total trips are not total cars.39:24 It's total cars times 2?39:28 Um, so the total is entering and leaving.39:32 So correct.39:34 So half of those would be entering and half would be exiting, right?39:37 So it's not 2,283 vehicles, it's half of that, correct?39:44 Because you're counting them coming in and you're counting them leaving.39:48 Yes.39:48 So a trip is reflective of, of 2, correct?40:00 Okay.40:00 Nicholas Hans, 28 Webster Street.40:02 I appreciate the analogy about the golf course.40:06 I appreciated his curiosity around events and things like that, or promotion to drive traffic to the venue.40:12 Yep.40:13 Take— sticking with that golf course analogy, think about like people PGA Championship events.40:18 Will the group that's organizing this plan to attract competitions that are going to gather larger quantities of people?40:26 Good question.40:29 Uh, to answer the question, yes, that's part of our long-term goal, to have, to have some events.40:34 If, if that were to occur, we would have to coordinate with the Middleborough Police Department and MassDOT and the local, uh, the local decision makers to make sure we have it properly staffed and staged so there's no issues.40:48 Would you have enough parking to handle that?40:51 We think so.41:03 Okay, did you— go for it.41:05 I'm going back.41:06 I'd like to ask that we try to take that into account.41:09 In some of these traffic studies, it doesn't seem like that was taken into account at all.41:14 So under this new light, you know, I think that's something we should consider.41:22 So now that that has been brought up, would you guys, you know, have some sort of a shuttle service from either the airport or to and from the T to get those higher number of people there as opposed to— We've actually— we're actually considering considering that, especially with the train station being down the street.41:40 So if there was an event, we'd have to maybe offer some type of shuttle service or something.41:47 Again, I think the first— whatever event happens first is going to be a learning curve for everyone.41:55 So how do you work those into numbers when you have special events?41:59 Let's say there's, I don't know, I'll throw a number, 10 a year.42:03 Maybe it's really 3, maybe it's 20, I don't know.42:06 So how would you work those in?42:09 Sure.42:09 So I mean, again, the traffic study does reflect— we're trying to show, you know, a typical average day.42:14 So as was mentioned, you know, if there was to be an event, there would have to be some traffic management, you know, in place working with Middleborough Police Department and, you know, making sure things were in place to minimize impacts.42:27 But, you know, looking at an average day is really the the general purpose of the study rather than, you know, those, those peak events.42:34 We always kind of use the analogy, you're not going to do parking counts on Black Friday.42:39 So, you know, there are events again that have special circumstances, and, and we would work with the town to make sure that there was proper, you know, staffing in place to make sure that was handled.42:51 But have you ever done studies where you work with the owner to figure out, okay, they can put so many people on premises.43:01 I mean, I'm assuming there's a number where you, you're going to reach and you've maxed out, right, for the property.43:07 So you know that's the high end.43:09 You can only fit so many cars.43:12 But if you're going to do shuttle service, so that would be shuttle vans coming back and forth, have you done anything where you work with property owners and business owners to figure out an event number?43:25 And because how would you go to the town and know how many vehicles might be coming in that day?43:30 You'd have to have generated some type of number to present to the town.43:35 So usually we would work to put those, you know, traffic management practices in place and kind of stage those out, kind of planning for that event, not really knowing— I don't know that we would know the exact number.43:48 You know, as was mentioned, it would probably be a learning curve.43:51 The first event might not be as popular as future events.43:54 So, you know, using that first one and seeing what practices work best and then making adjustments is typically how something like that would be approached.44:04 So we couldn't work on one now is what you're saying?44:06 We wouldn't, because we know your maximum, you can't put more than into the site.44:12 We just come up with some kind of numbers that would be coming and going for an event.44:16 To me, this would be similar— it'd be similar to when the town holds an event on 44 in the parking lot there, and we have shuttle service coming from the town hall up to there, and we have the signs all at 44.44:27 I agree.44:27 I don't think there was a traffic plan when that first started, but they've learned over time.44:31 So, um, but we'd like to know what you can— well, I don't think we could do it right now, Joe.44:37 I, I, I don't think we're there.44:39 I think, you know, the you know, when the first one happens, I'm happy to come back and say, this is what we're doing, guys, what do you think?44:47 No problem.44:47 Is once we issue the permit, I got no way to bring you back.44:49 That's right, this is our one bite.44:51 So we, we unfortunately have to have that information.44:54 You can't just take any numbers and just put it in there.44:57 It's not like— and it wouldn't be any because again, your site only handles a certain number, so you know the maximum number.45:03 So, so you, you— I just want to make sure I understand you.45:06 We're asking a fictional traffic management plan is what we're— It's not fictional.45:10 You know the maximum you can put on your property for an event.45:14 If you did a great job and— I'm sorry, I'm looking at you.45:17 If you do a great job on your event and you really bang it out and maybe you're selling tickets or something like that, you'd sell out.45:27 So you couldn't put more onto the site is what I'm saying.45:31 So we know the max number.45:32 Well, I understand less, but it can't be more.45:34 I understand what you're asking.45:37 Um, you know, we haven't designed events for the surf park as events per se, but what I can say is that we're very committed to work out traffic management for events as they happen.45:54 We don't know the, the overall site is much bigger, as you know, and there might be opportunities to park in other parking lots eventually on that property, say a weekend, if, if other businesses are not there.46:10 So we, we don't know what, what the field is that we have to, to sort of play with, but I, I want to assure you that we will be working with the town on a management plan.46:21 We certainly have taken some comfort in the fact that we have the train station and all of that parking, got the high school and all of that potential parking.46:32 So shuttles are probably in the future, but we don't— we haven't— we need to get the park up and operational.46:41 We haven't really even discussed events to any great degree, but we will be having events for sure.46:47 So based on the park and similar parks that have had events?46:52 Would you guys be able to create numbers similar to that if it's roughly the same size and scope?46:58 Well, I think all we know is that there are just different types of events, you know, and we can, we can talk to other parks and see what the events look like.47:09 But yeah, just think, we just haven't done it as yet.47:11 A rough idea of exactly how many people would be there and Etc.47:19 So an event like that, and I'm throwing it out to the board and anybody else that might know, is it typically you have to go to the select board to get a permit to do when you start involving the police and, and MassDOT on, on things that are good?47:33 Because you're on— I'm anticipating that, you know, once we get through, uh, this level of permitting, we'll be talking to the— we have a lot of things still to work out with the the town, and sort of events is one of them, how we will manage those as well as, you know, other things.47:53 So we're open to that next round of discussion and certainly want to be a good neighbor.47:59 So I don't know, does that answer your question that you were asking about on the events?48:07 Okay.48:09 Mr.48:10 Chair.48:11 Nancy.48:12 So to go off on what Mike was saying— sorry, my kid's a big golfer— so I know that there are events around in certain areas, like, and they're small.48:27 There's, there's one up, um, heading towards Falmouth.48:30 It's a small little place, but they have big events, you know, like, so there should be areas that you can look at to get an idea, like some of those places.48:42 They must have— they must have had to do some type of study.48:46 I'm just saying, like, look, look into it maybe so that you can tell us, you know.48:52 Yeah, I mean, we kind of had this, um, kind of how we, you know, ended up talking to MassDOT with the trip generation.48:58 You know, it was hard to find something that is really apples apples with this.49:01 So, um, you know, looking at how many trips, you know, to your point, a golf course might generate on an event might have no application to how many, you know, trips and what type of event would be happening here.49:15 So it's hard to come up with a number taking into account— we might know the capacity of the wave pool itself, but in terms of visitors and spectators, it might be a whole different number.49:25 So without knowing the structure of the event It's tough to come up with a realistic number of what that would generate.49:35 That opens up another can of worms, too, with the spectators for any type of event for the surfing.49:41 Okay.49:41 Thank you.49:45 Mr.49:45 Chair?49:46 Sandy.49:47 Completely different question.49:51 In the peer review, There's— I— there's nothing in here in regards to the water consumption and the impact on the town water resources.49:59 And I know that that's the question that residents are asking and are concerned for.50:06 Uh, yeah.50:06 Um, is there any data on that?50:09 Well, the, the, the, the volume to fill the pool is roughly 8 million gallons.50:15 No, and over the course of the year, it's another 8 million gallons.50:18 And I might have my numbers wrong, but we've talked to the town.50:22 We'd like to connect to the municipal system, and there's no issues with fulfilling that volume of water.50:29 But has there been any study on it?50:31 It's— everybody's here, like, it's talking to DPW, it's talking— like, I just— like, that's just the concern for the residents that are out there.50:39 And just to have something, just to even have a peer review on it, well, I thought thought that it was going to be, and it's not in here.50:46 So I'm— yeah, I mean, confused as to why it's not, considering one of the biggest, um, reasons for coming to Middleborough was the water.50:58 And so not to have a peer review on it, it just doesn't— well, we've talked about— we've talked about the lagoon, we've talked about the stormwater, we've talked about the waste, um, the overflow, or the cleaning, the storage, the groundwater.51:16 We talked all about it.51:17 Yeah, but we don't have anything on a peer review, and I'd like to see that in a peer review just so that we can say that we answer the questions of our residents on the water.51:30 Because the water is the resources, not the development, not the— it's a private ownership And that's come— and, and we have to, um, respect that.51:40 But it is our resource, and not to have it in here just doesn't sit well with me.51:47 I, uh, my only answer to that is we've checked with Mike Bumpus.51:51 The town's only allowed to pull so much water under its water withdrawal permit.51:57 Um, Mike has said that the town could furnish this project with no issues.52:04 Um, I, I don't know what else to say to that point.52:07 I'm not sure what, what would need to be studied.52:12 Um, Tammy, did we get a letter?52:16 I don't remember.52:20 I don't remember getting anything specific.52:23 I thought we had asked the question.52:25 That's why we did.52:32 Without me digging through.52:43 Mike Orenberger had sent a letter and it was more of coordinating with them.52:49 They were concerned if we would do the private wells.52:51 We, um, yeah, no, design— there's a well on the property.52:55 I understand.52:56 Um, and you had originally— we're going to do a both mix of both?53:03 Well, well, well, at the time that would— that was, that was what we were thinking, but, um, I think it'd be better.53:09 It's all— you're pulling the water from the same, same resource.53:12 Yeah, no, I get that.53:13 Is what it is.53:13 So we, we— I don't think there's a supply issue, but that's, that's my own personal knowledge of what's, what's there.53:20 But, um, but it's not— I thought we had, I thought we had something from— I think we did, Darren.53:26 I have so much stuff in here.53:27 Okay, well, let's, uh, put a pin in— let's put a pin in that and we'll find it.53:32 Find that.53:37 So you would have to go to the select board to get a permit to utilize that amount of water?53:45 Uh, I think we'd have to go apply.53:48 Yeah, I think that's it, Joe, really.53:51 All right.53:52 Um, again, we, we haven't done this in a vacuum.53:54 When we first came to town, that was the first question.53:57 Oh, I know, right?53:58 Is there enough water to do this?54:00 I just thought in the plan, in the peer review, it just would have mentioned it in there.54:04 Yeah.54:05 And so I don't understand why it's not.54:09 So, and I know it's sometimes cart before the horse or something like that, but at some point we probably want to address, are you going to get a formal letter from one of the departments or even the select board saying that yes, in fact, this falls within the parameters of what you're going to get, so that if we approve it, that's part of this approval?54:33 So I would imagine any conditions that you guys are going to approve is to having a water source to service this project, be it a private well or a public well.54:48 Typically, when we go to the select board, they're the last stop on our permitting train.54:54 And the water will probably be the last stop.54:57 But like we said, this is an unusual project.54:59 So we may have to do things that may be out of order or something, just to make sure we have all the documentation.55:05 June 22nd was when you received that letter from, uh, just to make sure that we have everything in place.55:15 That is, this addresses the water.55:20 Yes, July 22nd, that's the one I've got.55:23 Well, I don't, I don't see who wrote it, but Um, but the source means the water connections.55:28 Yeah, it really has to come from that.55:32 No, but in regards to supply, and, um, yeah, that was Michael that wrote that.55:36 Um, the water line needs to be upgraded.55:43 So you have the letter?55:44 Yeah, yeah, it's pulled up on— so is he stating in there that he's certifying that there— that the town water resources.55:54 I mean, yeah, um, okay, um, for me, rather than piecemeal this, I'm just going to read the letter.56:07 This letter is from, uh, the town engineer, Michael Oberger, PE, town engineer.56:15 Letter is dated July 22nd, 2023.56:18 26, Zoning Board of Appeals.56:21 Subject is, uh, permit number 26-07, NESPA LLC Surf Park, DBW comments.56:28 Dear board members, at your request, I reviewed the subject special permit on behalf of the Department of Public Works Highway, Water, and Sewer Divisions.56:36 As part of the package, we received the following special permit site plans for the proposed wave garden, more 177 East Grove Street, Middleborough, Plymouth County, Mass., dated 6/25/2026, 15 sheets, prepared by Bowler.56:52 Traffic impact study proposed Fall Brook subdivision, dated May 2023, prepared by Bowman.56:58 Drainage report for NE SPLLC proposed wave garden.57:03 The department comments are as follows.57:08 One, the applicant will need a state highway access permit from MassDOT D5 for the modification of the driveway openings— opening, excuse me— and for the water tie-in.57:20 A copy of approved submittal plan set and permit shall be submitted to the town for their reckons.57:26 Applicant shall coordinate the water tie-in, uh, SHARPS, whatever that adjective means, permit with DPW.57:36 We have not thoroughly reviewed the traffic impact study— because this letter was dated back in July— recommends that the report reviewed by the zoning board review engineer and comments forwarded to the DPW based on our limited review of the documents.57:51 See the below for general comments.57:55 A, MassDOT will have a final say on the curb openings on the state highway, and modifications to state highway has to be be dedicated turning to state highway but has dedicated turning lanes from 28 into the facility be considered, which is where I had gotten that idea from.58:15 The report takes into consideration the future demands of traffic along 28 and the development of the former Friedman's Junkyard, currently modeled the Oasis at Middleborough.58:26 It is our understanding that another developer is proposing a different use for that site and is recommended to provide an additional analysis of the impact of that proposed development.58:37 I believe you probably included those numbers in your traffic study.58:41 Yes, because you— that was an approved plan previous.58:44 Yeah.58:45 Okay.58:47 Um, the report references similar traffic data for 2 similar wave pools were provided to Bowman It is recommended that this be incorporated into the report as an attachment so it can be reviewed by the engineer.59:03 Let's get to the water issues here.59:07 We have not thoroughly reviewed stormwater report.59:10 It is recommended that the report be reviewed by the Zoning Board's review engineer and comments forwarded to the DPW.59:17 In general, the post-development peak discharges are less than or equal to the pre-development, and the proposed project is infiltrating all runoff within the site.59:31 With the amount of water anticipated by the development, the water line in front of the property on Route 28 shall be upgraded.59:38 It is recommended that the water line be upgraded to a 16-inch water line from the intersection of Wareham Street and East Grove to the intersection of East Grove and Cherry.59:50 Based on our review of the proponent's ENF submittal, water withdrawal is anticipated to be between 8 million and 24 million gallons of water.1:00:07 The Water Department requests a stamped engineer letter that itemizes the anticipated water demand.1:00:14 Based on the anticipated water demand mentioned above, the water application— excuse me, I'm just reading too fast— the water application and development fees for this project totals approximately between $600,000 and $1.7 million.1:00:33 These fees are subject to change based on the review of the anticipated flow.1:00:39 The ENF document references 2 private wells proposed on the site.1:00:46 Are we still— are we planning to— we're not planning to do that anymore.1:00:50 That's okay.1:00:55 Okay, the detailed plans show the wells connections.1:00:58 We're not— we're not doing that.1:00:59 The size of the water main needs to be shown on the plans, a minimum of 8 inches.1:01:04 Cement-lined ductile iron Class 52 pipe shall be required.1:01:08 Okay, um, number 9 deals with fire suppression will be provided in all buildings.1:01:21 Um, so there's no, um, there's no certification, but nope, there's nothing in here that says they can't do the project Well, they're not saying that they can't, but they're not even stating what, if any, impact there is on the town's water resources.1:01:37 They're doing the water tie-ins, they're doing the discharge, they're doing the water line upgrade, but they're not discussing the overall consumption and if it's going to come in.1:01:48 We can ask for another letter.1:01:50 Um, I knew we had— I would like to see, can we ask for the peer you to review it.1:01:57 But they're gonna— they're gonna rely on what the DPW says.1:02:02 But that's fine.1:02:02 I'd like to see it though.1:02:04 So first thing, it's somewhere in there, it said something about a letter from the engineering firm.1:02:09 Yeah, that they want it stamped.1:02:10 Stamped engineering firm.1:02:12 That would be part of our application process.1:02:15 Yeah, we have to do a stamped letter.1:02:16 That's— that would be a problem if we can get— that would be the first step because that would be the start, and then they would have— well, I mean, based on, based on what you've told them and based on what was in the letter, I don't think it would be a stretch to have the town engineer give you a letter saying that we have adequate supply to cover the, the anticipated use, as long as someone stamps it, and so that the town can't come back and say, well, no, we don't have adequate I mean, I know that it shouldn't be an issue, but it's just— but it's just not— but it's just not here.1:02:51 And we're talking about the water, we're talking about our town's resources.1:02:56 That's a concern in regards to the residents.1:02:59 And I just think by overlooking that and not addressing it, it just doesn't sit well.1:03:06 But even with DPW, they went through everything, but they didn't talk about the resource, the water resource.1:03:11 The impact.1:03:12 I think he took— you're looking at it from the perspective of the DPW is looking at it and saying, okay, do we have enough to do this?1:03:17 If there wasn't, then it would have been something in the letter.1:03:19 Then say it.1:03:22 But they had already stated at various meetings that there wasn't an issue.1:03:26 Well, then put it in writing and say it.1:03:28 I just want to see it.1:03:29 And I don't think— I don't think I'm asking for— that's fine.1:03:32 I don't think I can do that.1:03:33 Being unreasonable for the ask.1:03:36 It's our— it's our— I just No, I don't think— no, no, no, I don't think that you— I wasn't saying to you, Darren.1:03:40 I was saying it to Michael.1:03:49 Listen, I could talk to DPW and see if they can generate something.1:03:56 But it would be nice to have a formal request of this is how much water the project's going to need.1:04:03 And then a formal response from the town saying, okay, we understand how much and we are stating yes, no, indifferent, whatever their answer is, that there won't be any impact on the town resources, the water resources.1:04:18 I don't think it's a big ask.1:04:21 I don't know if they'll say that.1:04:22 I mean, they're going to say— well, somebody will.1:04:24 They're going to say we have enough capacity under our— yeah, I mean, I'm not going to say what they're going to say and put it in, or in the wording of it.1:04:33 But you know what I'm trying— you know what I'm getting at.1:04:35 I do.1:04:37 And I don't think it's a big ask.1:04:41 I'll ask— I'll speak to DPW and see what I can get.1:04:44 Okay.1:04:44 I'm not saying no, I just don't know what they're willing to do.1:04:47 And if they— if they're not, I would love to see it in the peer review.1:04:51 I thought it wasn't here.1:04:52 So the letter requesting it would come from From Bowman.1:04:58 It said a stamped engineering letter.1:05:01 Oh no, that's part of the permit process.1:05:03 I know, but they'd like to have the formal— this is how much.1:05:06 We're trying to formalize this so there could be a formalized response.1:05:10 I will get conversation.1:05:12 I will get a letter from an engineer stating how much water.1:05:15 Okay, perfect.1:05:16 Fine.1:05:16 Yes, I can move that.1:05:17 Is that okay?1:05:18 Yeah.1:05:21 Thank you.1:05:24 And I had something just a little different too, because, um, we've discussed it.1:05:28 I mean, I have a lot with the backwash material.1:05:30 You guys said that you'd end up having to cart it off-site.1:05:33 Yeah.1:05:34 Do we— is there going to be a plan for that?1:05:36 Like, is that going to be in the final 2 of who's going to do it?1:05:40 No, that's, that's, that's, that'll be in the, uh, as part of the construction documents.1:05:44 All right, that's all I wanted to make sure.1:05:46 Thank Thank you.1:05:47 And one other thing, I think I recall from an earlier conversation on this too, you guys have some sort of an on-site filtration system where you're able to recycle a lot of the water, so it's not going to be like a continuous flow of use from— oh no, no, no, no, no.1:06:01 Yeah, it was like 5,000 gallons over the course of— I think it was 2 weeks, 3 weeks, whatever it was.1:06:08 Yeah.1:06:08 So if there's any way to have that part of the proposed package, the TPW, whatever you need to be done just to verify that it's not going to be 8 million gallons a week.1:06:19 So yes, you know, we're not overloading the system.1:06:23 Yeah, that would be the letter coming from the engineering firm saying this is— yeah, we already paid an amount.1:06:28 Yeah, gallons.1:06:31 Okay.1:06:38 Yep, I'm just going to take some questions.1:06:43 Thank you.1:06:43 Sarah Hans, 28 Webster Street.1:06:46 Um, I agree, I think at a bare minimum we need a peer-reviewed study on what this is going to do to our water.1:06:53 Even this letter doesn't reflect the current plan for water usage, which does not include the wells.1:07:01 So yeah, just echoing that.1:07:03 And then I think the wells.1:07:05 Sorry, we're not including the wells then?1:07:07 That's right.1:07:09 But this letter does reflect that, correct?1:07:13 That was— yeah, the project's changed since that letter.1:07:15 That's right.1:07:16 So I feel like we need an updated version.1:07:19 Um, I think secondly, I understand that all of the water on site is planned to be filtered before discharge.1:07:28 Um, is there any process of adding the water or making it similar to the Brooks water that it's going to be discharged into.1:07:41 I guess I'm wondering what all of this chemically treated water, even without the chemicals in it being discharged at a large volume, what the impact is going to have on— yeah, it has to be a natural ecosystem.1:07:57 That is going to have a certain pH, a certain temperature, a certain oxygenation.1:08:03 We went through this at the last meeting.1:08:04 Yeah, the last meeting.1:08:05 Yeah, it has to be treated.1:08:07 So it says— yeah, so in that meeting we talked about all of the chemicals that were in it being filtered out.1:08:14 It's regulated.1:08:15 Yep.1:08:16 And so what I'm asking is if that water is also being made to be similar to the water that it's being discharged into.1:08:23 So not just is the chlorine being taken out of it, but is that water even going to have the same pH as the brook that it's being discharged into?1:08:33 Yeah, we discussed this all about the last meeting.1:08:36 Before anything can get discharged, it has to be tested, and EPA sets the limits we have to meet.1:08:42 If we don't meet the effluent limits, we don't get our permit to discharge.1:08:45 So yeah, and they take the brook and the, uh, they'll take the temperature of the the brook, they'll take the pH, they'll, they'll do all their testing and say, this is what you got to meet, and we'll have to test for it before we discharge.1:08:57 Quincy Pratt from Sanborn Head was here last time.1:09:00 He spoke about the testing we have to do and all that stuff.1:09:03 So I think we had addressed it at the last meeting.1:09:06 Thank you.1:09:07 And the water does go into basins, so it sits and then it gets filtered down through, infiltrates.1:09:13 Yeah.1:09:16 Um, another question, just as far as the amount of volumes, um, that were discussed earlier, it was $8 million we saw around.1:09:23 I'm seeing that this letter is estimating up to $24 million.1:09:27 Yep.1:09:27 Um, I would ask that the town also digs a bit deeper and ask for the peer review to take into account seasonal usage.1:09:34 Obviously the evaporation in July and August will be a lot different than off-peak seasons.1:09:40 I don't know if that would addressed previously, but I think that's something that will have a tremendous impact on the town's ability to supply water to our houses if they're consuming in excess of, you know, 10x what their normal consumption is at one point in time.1:10:00 I'm looking to the back of the room.1:10:03 Oh, can you— can you— again, we did that the first meeting.1:10:06 We talked about that.1:10:07 I You know, specific questions about the evaporation.1:10:10 Obviously, the November versus July, there's obviously more water demand to make sure the water level is at the correct level.1:10:18 Can you depending on put that in your letter so that it's that will be in the letter?1:10:22 So that everybody yeah, you know, letter may not come from me.1:10:25 It may come from Wave God, but it will be a letter that will state okay anticipated water uses for the lagoon for all the you know the restaurants and everything, and then it could be put.1:10:33 In there about the seasonal impacts and how there's a greater demand in July than there is in November, for example.1:10:40 Perfect.1:10:40 Thank you.1:10:40 Thank you.1:10:41 That way the town can respond to that kind of information.1:10:50 Kristen Thiebaud, Black Brook Paths.1:10:52 Um, so part of the MEPA review required you guys to complete a hydrogeographical geological survey.1:10:59 Are you guys no longer doing that?1:11:05 We're not doing any study.1:11:07 We're not doing the private wells.1:11:08 So that was based on you using town and well water?1:11:13 No, it's based on the use of private wells, not the town well.1:11:16 Yeah, we're not doing the wells.1:11:20 It's all, it's all going to be town water.1:11:22 Your original plan was for 65,000 or so gallons a day from your— from the wells that you're currently no longer building, but also 10,000 gallons a day from the town.1:11:32 You were looking at both, right?1:11:35 We were.1:11:35 The project's changed.1:11:37 So why are they— they should still be required to complete the survey because the wells— you shouldn't be able to— well, it's the town well.1:11:45 Yeah, it's the town well.1:11:47 Yep.1:11:47 You're still pulling from the same subbasin, which is already very stressed.1:11:51 If you check the SWMMI data, it is already— which is out of date, so it's probably more stressed than the SWMMI data is showing.1:11:58 This is still a stressed subbasin.1:12:04 It is a level 4 biological category and a level 3 groundwater category, and that is at least 10 years old, that data.1:12:11 20.1:12:12 Yeah, possibly more.1:12:14 If you're going to speak, you got to come to the microphone.1:12:20 Nobody at home can hear you.1:12:24 Brian Thiebaud, Blackbrook Path.1:12:27 The last meeting that I was in with this gentleman, it was stated that they would not be using the wells, that the wells would still be built.1:12:36 That was what was verbally spoken during that meeting.1:12:39 So our concerns is that there's a little bit of things are not clear with what their plans actually are.1:12:49 So I second what this board member is stating.1:12:53 Everything needs to be in writing.1:12:55 Everything.1:12:56 Um, to clarify what my wife is saying, the current water— the current water subbasin for the project as proposed is 24094.1:13:05 The basin currently has 5 separate public water supplies located at 3 different sites.1:13:10 One of these 3 is a town site, Tisbaquin GP Well 1 and 2.1:13:14 The last survey of this subbasin was in 2002 and showed the basin as a biological category 4 and a groundwater category of 3.1:13:22 The current rating is out of date and must be brought current to determine actual stress levels.1:13:27 According to the Massachusetts River Alliance, Massachusetts Watershed Associations, and MWRA, it is illegal to add new withdrawal sites to Category 4 and Category 5 subbasins.1:13:40 Now that's speaking to the wells that they are saying that they are no longer putting on the site.1:13:46 However, that would impact our wells, correct?1:13:50 Our town wells as well.1:13:52 Any town or developer that puts a new withdrawal site in a Category 4 or 5 basin could be subject to legal action by the state.1:14:01 8.1:14:01 They're not.1:14:02 I'm— as of right now, they're not.1:14:05 Yeah, well, that's the verbally— I, I want to see this in writing.1:14:09 Where's the new plan that doesn't have the wells on it?1:14:12 Because the last plan I saw still had the wells on it.1:14:15 And if they're going to draw up to 24 million gallons from the town, can we see how many gallons are coming from this subbasin?1:14:25 Because this subbasin Well, part of a larger basin that is also stressed, probably not as much as this subbasin, but we need to know how much water is coming out of the subbasin for the sake of us drinking.1:14:43 How many new houses were put in South Middleborough since 2002 that have wells that drink from this groundwater?1:14:57 Mr.1:14:57 Chair, thank you.1:14:57 Ask Mike a question.1:15:00 Sure, Mike.1:15:01 Um, I've done a lot of research, as you know, um, on this property.1:15:08 As far as I know, um, somewhere back in the early 1900s, there was something written up about the well, and I believe there are 2 wells on there.1:15:20 One well was done early before the 1900s, and another one was done in 1900.1:15:27 But I know it's stipulated in an heir thing of who can draw off the well through the Millers.1:15:37 And I believe there's 2 wells, at least 2 wells on the property still, correct?1:15:44 I can't speak to that.1:15:45 I'm aware of one that's servicing the house by the street.1:15:49 Okay.1:15:49 All right.1:15:50 I just wanted to make sure because I thought there was another.1:15:52 I'm only— yeah, I was just dating back.1:15:54 All right.1:15:55 Thank you.1:15:58 So if there's one well that you're aware of that's servicing the house, that's not on the property that you have anyway, so you wouldn't be able to utilize that.1:16:07 Would not.1:16:08 Okay.1:16:09 So on the property that would be owned by Wave Garden.1:16:14 Are there any current wells there now?1:16:16 No.1:16:17 Okay.1:16:22 And there are no plans to build one?1:16:24 Not at this time.1:16:25 Thank you.1:16:28 So when we do get an updated plan with everything on it, that— there wouldn't be any proposed well?1:16:34 Yeah, like I said, it's our preference to, to Connect to the municipal system.1:16:38 Yeah.1:16:40 Okay.1:16:43 I just want— I want to answer everybody's questions.1:16:45 Understood.1:16:46 I mean, it's great questions, so we just need to have that documented.1:16:50 Okay.1:16:53 What's next?1:16:54 I don't know.1:16:55 It's your meeting.1:16:57 Oh, now it's my— I see where we're going.1:17:00 All right.1:17:03 You have anything else to propose for tonight?1:17:06 Uh, Mr. Chairman, um, since we're effectively done with the civil and I sense that we're very close to wrapping up the traffic, what I'd like to do is similar to what we did at Campus 44.1:17:19 I'll start putting together a decision for you guys to take a look at.1:17:23 The yeoman's work is on me, so, um, we didn't have town council doing it.1:17:29 I'd get it over to Tammy.1:17:31 She could send it to KP.1:17:32 They can do what they're going to do with it.1:17:34 And then hopefully when we go back and forth, you guys will have a draft decision in front of you to look at.1:17:39 Will we— will we have new plans, the updated plans, soon?1:17:45 Well, there's really the only— the only real update is to the radius.1:17:49 Um, and if, if you want final, final design plans, we'll clean them up and you can get them submitted.1:17:56 Yeah, it would be good to see the— I don't know, are we speaking out of turn?1:18:01 Is there still a lot of work to be done?1:18:04 No.1:18:05 So you reduce— you reduce some of it.1:18:07 So because, yeah, it shrunk, the project shrunk.1:18:09 No, so like you said, the plans are done.1:18:11 The only thing we're talking about is getting that one radius change.1:18:14 And like, I'd rather— I can do it now, but a lot of times you just do it after the conditional approval, right?1:18:19 Because there's no major changes to make.1:18:20 So the radius— talking about one radius, changing it from 10 to 15, and removing the 2 wells in the plan.1:18:26 So I mean, you just make those conditions.1:18:29 I mean, I'm just trying to keep from doing— redoing it from our original set.1:18:33 Yes, yes, yes.1:18:34 So these are the revised plans that addressed all of the Apex comments.1:18:37 Apex comments came back, just the radius.1:18:39 That's— that was it.1:18:40 Okay.1:18:40 All right.1:18:44 So again, we still have Conservation Commission.1:18:46 I, I don't want to do them one, one time.1:18:48 That's what I'm getting at.1:18:49 It's so minor that just be conditional with approval.1:18:51 Okay.1:18:52 All right.1:18:52 That's if that works for the board.1:18:54 Well, when do you— as far as the, the radius, would— when would that be put in?1:19:01 Are you— what do you mean put?1:19:03 That's— you're saying that that's going to be updated?1:19:07 Yeah.1:19:07 So, so you're waiting till the very end?1:19:09 Waiting for MassDOT?1:19:09 No, no, no.1:19:11 No, no, no, no, the rate— the radius here is off the— uh, it's into our site right there.1:19:16 That's the 15-foot radius.1:19:18 That's off the roadway.1:19:19 Okay.1:19:19 Yeah.1:19:21 Okay, so this has everything in it of reducing— like, didn't you eliminate some buildings?1:19:29 Yes.1:19:30 Yeah, showing the huts as phase 2.1:19:33 The reduction in the wellness center is off.1:19:35 Again, that's— this has all the update, all that.1:19:37 We talk about one of the basins needing a Um, a fence.1:19:41 Did we talk about that?1:19:42 I thought we did.1:19:43 Yeah, and we talked about the fence going around too.1:19:47 Yeah, being higher than 4 feet perimeter fence.1:19:50 They were going to check it.1:19:52 I don't think there was a— yeah, yeah, we have a fence.1:19:56 Is that like a fence because of pay fence, but not around the whole 20 acres?1:20:01 No, that was not discussed.1:20:02 No.1:20:03 So, but there was definitely a fence that needed.1:20:05 I thought because of the smoke— yeah, the case, it was, was it 3 to 1?1:20:09 And it was— I was talking about the— whoa, oh, defense.1:20:13 Yeah, yeah, yeah, we said that if you guys made that recommendation, we could, we could add that.1:20:17 So I— last time we spoke, there's no— I think you guys were back and forth, like some thought you should have defense, not.1:20:22 But if you want us to have defense, that's part of the condition we can add.1:20:24 That's just based on— we always go off of the subdivision regulations.1:20:29 So if the fence is required for the basin of a subdivision, it would be required here.1:20:34 Yeah.1:20:34 Are you not going to put a fence around the lagoon?1:20:37 No.1:20:37 Before it was supposed to— no, never.1:20:40 No, I, I don't know, you might have to check into state law on that.1:20:44 Again, that's not— that it's not a pool.1:20:47 It follows different regulations.1:20:48 It doesn't fall like a normal pool where you think it has to be fenced in.1:20:51 Totally different regulations than a typical swimming pool.1:20:54 That's 14 feet in one area.1:20:55 Yes, but that was never— that was never discussed about putting a fence around the lagoon.1:21:00 I'm discussing it now.1:21:02 I'm— Mike can answer that.1:21:03 Yeah, we're not proposing a fence, Nancy.1:21:06 I mean, again, people can walk out.1:21:09 Well, we're going to have lifeguards stationed all around it.1:21:12 Um, I don't think after hours— you know, that's what I'm thinking, after hours.1:21:19 You know, you can't keep everybody out of everything.1:21:22 You know, it's the safety.1:21:24 That's why I asked if you were going to have security on site.1:21:27 Do you remember that?1:21:28 I do.1:21:29 And that's— we're going to— I'm sure that's part of our planning.1:21:33 Again, we're not there yet, but our final program is going to be— I don't see what the benefit of a fence around the lagoon would be.1:21:42 Yeah, I don't feel comfortable with a 14-foot drop.1:21:45 I mean, I swim in the water.1:21:46 He's grown up falling into Well, it's 14.1:21:48 Yeah, you're going into the water, but I mean, yeah, what age?1:21:51 You know, it's like you get drownings all the time.1:21:53 Sure.1:21:55 Um, all right, so it's not a pool, it's a lagoon.1:22:01 It's a lagoon.1:22:02 It's similar to a lake.1:22:04 Are there state regulations saying that you don't need it?1:22:09 This isn't a pool.1:22:12 We— they don't This— not the lakes.1:22:14 No, you don't get it.1:22:15 That's what I'm saying.1:22:16 You don't— but that's— does District Pond have a fence around it?1:22:19 No, but that, that's a natural occurring phenomenon as opposed to this being built.1:22:23 I just wasn't sure, is there something from the state levels?1:22:27 I'm unaware of any state requirement that this be fenced.1:22:42 All right.1:22:47 I'm sorry.1:22:49 Well, I'm not going to say anything.1:22:50 You were going to say something and you thought better of it, so that's up to you.1:22:57 Okay.1:22:58 No, I'm going to wait until you ask us if we have questions or want to add anything.1:23:03 Yeah.1:23:04 I'm just going back and I just want to make sure.1:23:07 So you have to do some updates in regards to the plan, um, but I'm still hanging my hat on the peer review to be done for the consumption of the water.1:23:21 You've asked, we're going to do it.1:23:22 We are.1:23:22 Okay, I just wanted to make sure.1:23:24 And I didn't— can I just speak that?1:23:25 Yeah, again, Mike, into the peer review.1:23:27 Like, if you talk about Apex, they wouldn't— they wouldn't review that.1:23:30 As Meg mentioned, it would be a letter coming from you— yeah, from the team, right?1:23:34 Me or part of the team saying exactly what the water needs are, including seasonal.1:23:38 Then it would be the DPW sign-off that they can provide that water.1:23:42 Apex would not get involved with that.1:23:43 You can ask them, but they would not get involved with that.1:23:45 And I think that would be their answer, to be honest with you.1:23:48 Ask the DPW.1:23:49 It'd be like, ask the authority.1:23:51 I understand that.1:23:52 Yeah, that's not a problem.1:23:54 Yeah.1:23:56 That cover everything you want?1:23:58 Yes, we're going to get— we're going to get a letter.1:24:00 That's what you want.1:24:01 Do we also, um, Mike, have a progress on the DRGP process?1:24:07 I mean, I know they closed it out, but it was— you guys had it.1:24:10 Yeah, we haven't filed that yet.1:24:13 That'll get— um, we'll wrap this process up.1:24:16 And, um, so to take that step, the actual water system needs to be designed.1:24:21 That hasn't been designed yet.1:24:23 Once that's designed, then we can go test the Fall Brook for, for what's in it that they need it to match.1:24:30 And at that point, we'll file for the, the DRGP permit.1:24:34 But yeah, I have no idea what it is.1:24:35 It's new to me.1:24:36 So, all right, that's what I figured it was.1:24:38 Thank you.1:24:42 But there are a lot of— defer to this list before we Mr.1:24:47 Chair, there are a lot of defer to the ZBA on this, and there's a lot of, um, unconditioned— like, there's a lot of conditional within the whole report.1:24:57 So, mm-hmm, just saying.1:25:03 Well, do you have a specific issue, or are you just— no, I'm just making sure that, you know, because a lot of this that's closed down, make sure the board's aware of its authority.1:25:12 So, okay, okay.1:25:14 No, I know.1:25:21 If you saw something that stuck out that you wanted to talk about, we can bring it up.1:25:25 Yeah, I didn't.1:25:27 Okay.1:25:29 Anybody else have a concern, question, something we forgot?1:25:37 So in the beginning, we had sort of a I know, like, no, I'm just stalling for time.1:25:46 So in the beginning you did a synopsis of the business.1:25:51 As this process has evolved, the business has kind of changed.1:25:57 Can you update that to see where, where you are now and what it is that you're— what's the ask now of the board compared to what was in the beginning.1:26:07 I don't think the ask has changed.1:26:08 Well, the ask is the same, I guess, but the overall business plan that was originally presented, it's evolved.1:26:15 I think it's slightly smaller than it was.1:26:18 Yeah, it's smaller.1:26:20 You know, the hours maybe are a little more refined.1:26:24 Essentially the same.1:26:26 Yeah.1:26:26 So maybe you can just punch it up.1:26:27 Of course.1:26:30 Else was looking for something like that.1:26:32 I was just thinking about it.1:26:34 The scope has changed.1:26:36 Yeah, it's phases now, but draft.1:26:39 Yeah, let's, let's start that process and, um, we'll get the letters we're looking for and, um, see where we come out.1:26:53 Any other questions from the board before I entertain a motion to continue.1:26:58 I just have one comment.1:26:59 Go ahead, um, please.1:27:01 So Lost Shore, uh, Surf Park in Scotland is the closest, and it's 3 times the acreage, but it's closest in scope to this, uh, project.1:27:14 It's— yes, that's probably the most comparable.1:27:17 Yeah, so that, that's— don't— you know, not that we have the same type of numbers, but if we do have to you know, kind of review something like that for any events, or, you know, what their consumption and stuff is.1:27:27 It may be, you know, easy to do that if it's— yeah, I think we can, uh, we can get some, some information.1:27:34 I just figured I'd throw it out there so that way we're not— sense.1:27:38 Thank you.1:27:40 One more.1:27:41 I found one.1:27:42 Um, the snow storage areas, Mike, uh, where did you put those?1:27:46 Oh, I forget.1:27:50 There's another plan.1:27:51 This plan is shaded.1:27:54 That would be— ah, you might have to zoom in.1:27:57 I know this area here where the wellness center used to be.1:28:01 Um, and there's some other locations.1:28:03 They should be labeled on here.1:28:04 There's none back on there.1:28:06 It's up to the front, like the front parking lot area.1:28:13 So right here, if you zoom in here, I believe that's just no storage area.1:28:18 There's another area, same, that type of shade, same area.1:28:22 I think this is down in here also.1:28:24 So yep, our new expert.1:28:28 As long as it's noted on the plan.1:28:30 Yep, that's all fine.1:28:31 Yep.1:28:39 Okay, I'll entertain the motion to continue to, uh, January 14th.1:28:44 No, December 10th.1:28:46 Excuse me.1:28:48 So moved.1:28:49 Second.1:28:50 Motion made and seconded.1:28:52 All those in favor?1:28:54 Aye.1:28:54 Opposed?1:28:55 Motion carries unanimously.1:28:56 Thank you.1:28:57 Thank you.1:28:59 Where it tend to go?1:29:02 There we go.1:29:03 I was doing Good until it went sideways.1:29:09 It went back to a pool.1:29:12 Okay, item number 4 on the agenda.1:29:18 Um, what does that even mean?1:29:22 We'll hear the petition of, uh, Kurt— is it Radik?1:29:27 I don't know.1:29:28 48C, short drive.1:29:30 Shore Drive, Mattapoisett, Mass., 02739, relative to his request to be granted a special permit pursuant to Section 4.5.3 of the Middleborough Zoning Bylaw to allow for the construction of a 7,440-square-foot storage building.1:29:48 The existing office warehouse building, parentheses, Bay State Piping, is 15,200 square feet, creating a total of 22,640 square feet.1:30:02 The subject property located at 467 Wareham Street, Middleborough Assessor's Map 087, Lot 3285, in the GU zoning district.1:30:13 Declare the hearing open and the floor is yours.1:30:15 Good evening.1:30:16 Good evening, sir.1:30:17 How are you?1:30:18 Very good, how are you?1:30:19 Good, good.1:30:19 For the record, uh, Niles Bigger from Zenith Consulting Engineers, uh, here on behalf of the applicant and owner, 467 Wareham LLC.1:30:29 Um, so we are here before you, um, to request that the Middleborough Zoning Board of Appeals makes a determination under Sections 4.53 and 9.42 of the Middleborough Zoning Bylaws that the adverse effects of increasing the square footage of the gross floor area, um, of the existing building, proposed building, from 15,200 square feet, um, in the proposed building, um, of 7,440 square feet, uh, will increase it to 22,640 square feet, will not, will not outweigh the benefits, um, uh, the beneficial impacts to the town or within the neighborhood.1:31:13 Um, in support of this, I offer, uh, the following 5 points.1:31:17 One, um, the site is, um, appropriate for the proposed use and structure.1:31:23 The site's located, um, in the General Use X zoning district.1:31:29 Um, the existing, uh, building is approximately 15,200 square feet in size and is used for warehouse and office space, uh, or office purposes.1:31:38 The proposed 7,440-square-foot building will replace existing, um, existing fabric tents that are located on the property, and the building will now be used for dry storage.1:31:53 The existing and proposed uses are allowed as of right in the GUX, uh, general use zoning district.1:32:00 Point 2, adequate and appropriate will be provided to ensure proper operations of the use and structure.1:32:13 There will be wall-mounted lights on this, on the building itself, typical of this kind of building.1:32:20 There'll be downward-facing shields to ensure that there's no light going off the property, even though this is really in the middle of a property.1:32:27 There's no, no concern with that at all.1:32:30 On-site dumpster is placed— is going to be placed on a concrete pad with a privacy fence and a gate for trash removal.1:32:40 Drainage is being controlled through an infiltration basin, which is going to be— which has been designed to comply with stormwater management standards to the maximum feasible compliance.1:32:50 This is considered a redevelopment project.1:32:53 Oh, it's kind of a mix between a redevelopment project and a new construction.1:32:58 What we've done is we've proposed an infiltration basin that will capture the roof runoff from the proposed building, and it's also capturing some of the water that's coming off the existing gravel parking area, gravel storage area that's there.1:33:14 So it's a net improvement from what's on the site now.1:33:17 Currently, there's no drainage structures on the property at all.1:33:21 You have any catch basins at all?1:33:22 No, there's nothing.1:33:23 Okay, that's correct.1:33:26 Oh, all right.1:33:27 Um, the proposed building, um, is a dry storage, uh, warehouse, and so there's no water or, uh, septic system proposed to the building.1:33:38 Um, as it— the only thing that will be there is— that will be provided is, uh, electric— electricity.1:33:44 Uh, point 3, traffic flow and, um, safety, including parking and loading, and adequate, uh, and will be adequate, uh, and there will be no nuisance of services, uh, to vehicles or pedestrians.1:33:58 The total parking spaces required for the existing and proposed building are combined 49 spaces.1:34:04 A total of 50 spaces is proposed, provided with 2 handicap spaces provided.1:34:14 There is more than adequate space for vehicular traffic on the property and maneuverability.1:34:18 It's a, as I stated, it's a big wide open gravel area.1:34:23 Right now it was just being used as, as you know, it was Bay State Piping.1:34:27 It was storage of piping and stockpiles of material everywhere.1:34:30 That's being cleaned up and there's more than enough room within this area for maneuverability.1:34:38 Point 4, this has already been somewhat addressed, but to reiterate, the proposed building will not have water or septic.1:34:47 It will be provided with electricity, and it will be— all that electricity will be provided by the local utility company.1:34:59 Point 5, the use involved will not be detrimental to the, um, establishment of the future character, character of the neighborhood and town, and adjacent to appropriate conditions, and subject to appropriate conditions or safeguards if deemed necessary.1:35:18 It is our opinion that the, um, continued use of the site for office, warehouse, and storage purposes is not detrimental to the, um, establishment or future character of the, uh, GU zoning district.1:35:32 So that's kind of the breakdown of the site.1:35:36 We understand that the application will need to go before your review engineer, you know, for, you know, just to go over the general civil character, the civil engineering of the property.1:35:48 This will also have to go in front of the Middleborough Conservation Commission because there's a small portion of the work that falls within their jurisdiction.1:35:57 Of within 100 feet of a PBW.1:36:00 Um, that's about it.1:36:01 I'd be happy to answer any questions that the board has.1:36:06 Uh, questions from the board?1:36:11 So Tammy, can you move up to the next— I think it's the next page.1:36:16 So what are we looking at there on the site?1:36:20 Where is that on the site?1:36:22 So the existing building— so yeah, so we tried to do a blowup of the layout.1:36:26 Uh, where is it in relation to these?1:36:28 So the existing building is to the— well, I guess it'd be to the east.1:36:31 You can see a portion of it there.1:36:33 That's the building.1:36:34 That's the existing building there.1:36:36 Uh, the proposed buildings.1:36:37 Got it.1:36:38 So that's— got it.1:36:40 Yeah.1:36:40 All right, so the entrance comes in from the, the east side of that.1:36:44 Oh, excuse me, the west side of that.1:36:45 Um, so is this where on the original— on the other drawing, uh, the other If you go back to trailer, Connex, canopy, Connex.1:36:56 So yeah, so this is flipped 90 degrees clockwise from the— because that view is rotated.1:37:03 So the— so where would that— I don't happen to have a pointer.1:37:07 Yeah, Joe, I kind of put it right there.1:37:10 Yeah, that's what I'm saying.1:37:11 That's— yep, that's roughly where it is, where it says trailer, Connex.1:37:16 No.1:37:16 Yes.1:37:19 Did you see it?1:37:22 So am I wrong?1:37:23 Am I wrong?1:37:24 No, I'm sorry, it's right here.1:37:26 It's— yeah, that's correct.1:37:27 Yeah, that's correct.1:37:28 You had it right on the right.1:37:29 So it's— so it's— we go to the next, the other slide.1:37:34 So where it says trailer?1:37:36 Yes, yes, that's correct.1:37:38 Yes, yes, yes.1:37:39 Trailer connects, canopy connects.1:37:41 It's, it's in this general.1:37:43 Yeah, that's correct.1:37:44 A portion of it's on gravel area, and a portion of the, the work is being done within an existing wood area that's going to be cleared.1:37:51 Okay.1:37:52 Just for, just for to allow— because we can't pull it too far forward because we have to allow access to the back of the existing building that's there.1:38:01 And then the drain— you can see the drainage basin that's located, uh, the infiltration basin that's located to the side there on the plan.1:38:08 So that's heading towards the street?1:38:11 No, no, that's actually— no, that's— nope, that's actually running parallel with the street.1:38:14 Parallel with the street.1:38:15 Yeah, correct.1:38:16 Okay, sir.1:38:17 And then the parking areas, those are, those are just designated to show that we have more than enough room for the parking area.1:38:24 This is over a gravel area, so it won't necessarily be striped, but it'll be just to show that there is designated area for it.1:38:33 And then if you look— I'm sorry, Tammy, if you don't mind, uh, scroll down just a little bit on this sheet.1:38:38 And go to the bottom right.1:38:42 That detail there where you see the other parking spaces, that is a— so currently in front of the existing building where the entrance comes in, there's a parking area there that's being used for the warehouse building, the existing building, and the existing office space.1:38:58 It's not striped, it's not— it's just kind of an open area that's being used as needed.1:39:03 What we did was we we designated that there's more— there's actually, if you look on the aerial, there's 19 cars parked there.1:39:10 I'm sorry, 20 cars parked there.1:39:11 We've shown that we could fit 19 with 2 handicap spaces.1:39:15 Um, so there's more than enough there.1:39:18 Um, you know, just— we just wanted to show that we could designate it.1:39:22 Will be striped.1:39:24 So there's a total— again, there's 49 required by zoning.1:39:30 Um, there's 50, you know, that we're showing.1:39:32 We, I mean, we have more than enough space on site for that.1:39:36 What's the Lot 1?1:39:37 I'm sorry, is Lot 1— what's Lot 1?1:39:40 So when— what happened was this was all one big parcel, and there was like, there was 3 different parcels, there was 3 different Form As that were on it.1:39:47 Okay, so this was just known as Lot 1 of that Form A.1:39:52 And is this just their material that's just out in the area in the back?1:39:57 That was— yeah, it was all base day piping.1:39:58 That's correct.1:40:01 Is the house part of that lot?1:40:03 No.1:40:03 What it was, it's not now.1:40:05 Okay.1:40:05 Uh, that's actually part of Lot 3.1:40:08 Um, there's a— there's a— um, that's sold.1:40:11 That's somebody, a different owner on that now.1:40:13 Okay.1:40:15 Well, you referenced the trailer, so I understood.1:40:19 Well, you're I see you're talking about this.1:40:22 And do you— Mr.1:40:25 Chair, may I ask a question?1:40:26 Absolutely.1:40:27 Um, and so this, I guess, a warehouse, but all you have in is electricity in there?1:40:33 There's nothing else?1:40:34 No, no bathroom, just dry storage?1:40:37 There won't be any water, there won't be any septic, nothing.1:40:40 Okay.1:40:43 And are they— how do they get material out of the dry storage?1:40:48 Like, is— there's bays all across the whole front.1:40:50 If you see those thick lines in the front of the building, so if you're facing down towards the bottom of the screen, uh, there's bays all throughout that.1:40:57 Okay.1:41:00 Yes, there was a couple letters submitted.1:41:05 Um, first letter is from the Middleboro Fire Department, uh, stated October 19th, 2026.1:41:12 In regards to 467 Wareham Street, the Zoning Board of Appeals— Middleborough Fire Department has reviewed the appeal for 467 Wareham Street.1:41:22 The Middleborough Fire Department requires that all applicable Massachusetts fire codes, standards, and regulations be adhered to.1:41:28 The structure will need a licensed fire alarm company to submit smoke CO2 detector plans for review and associated permit fees.1:41:37 Respectfully, Captain Michael Ellie.1:41:41 Um, also have a letter from the planning board to the Zoning Board of Appeals.1:41:46 This letter is dated October 27th, 2026.1:41:51 Um, the planning department is in receipt of the above-referenced special permit application and plans requesting to the construction of a 7,440-square-foot storage building.1:42:01 The existing office warehouse building parentheses, base state piping is 15,200 square feet, thereby creating a total of 22,640 square feet, which is within the Zoning Board of Appeals purview.1:42:16 I recommend either outside review or internal review by the town engineer of the stormwater management report and the plans proposing— and proposing the enlargement or regrading needed to create the larger infiltration basin.1:42:31 If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to contact me, Ian Bradley, town planner.1:42:36 Um, I believe those are the only 2.1:42:39 Was that the only 2 we got?1:42:43 Oh wait, excuse me.1:42:46 Um, this letter is dated October 26th, 2026.1:42:52 It's from the Conservation Commission, Patricia Cassidy.1:42:58 On behalf of the Middleborough Conservation Commission, I've reviewed the documents for the above-mentioned application with the Zoning Board of Appeals and have the following comments.1:43:05 One, the portion of the proposed work is within Zone A of a state surface water protection zone, which is also outstanding resource water.1:43:15 2, the property is not mapped— is not a mapped area under the Division of Fisheries and Wildlife natural Heritage or Endangered Species Program and does not have any certified or potential vernal pools.1:43:27 3, there is some area on the property within a FEMA Zone X. I don't know what that means.1:43:36 Number 4, the work is proposed within 100 feet of the buffer zone of the bordering vegetative wetland and will require a filing of notice of intent with the Conservation Commission under the Mass Wetlands Protection Act, Mass General Laws Chapter 131, Section 40, and Regulations 310 CMR 10, Section CMR 10.1:43:57 Excuse me.1:43:59 The property is within the WRPD Zone 3.1:44:02 Any stormwater peer review the ZBA has conducted, the Conservation Commission will warrant a copy of.1:44:10 All right, so So we'll send it out.1:44:17 Yep.1:44:17 To get the stone.1:44:19 Well, we can send it to the town engineer.1:44:21 We can do that either way.1:44:25 Okay, we can do it to Pat.1:44:29 Yeah, just need you to cover the fee.1:44:31 That's no problem.1:44:32 Perfect.1:44:32 If you just let us know, we'll, we'll have a check.1:44:35 Thank you.1:44:36 Thank you.1:44:36 While you're here, I'm going to ask about the basin.1:44:39 So the bottom of the basin is showing 107.1:44:43 Um, I think they had a note that it went up to 110.1:44:49 The top is 110.1:44:49 I see 111, but yeah, it's not real.1:44:52 It's 110.1:44:53 It's 110.1:44:54 Yeah, I know.1:44:54 2 feet of working depth.1:44:56 Okay.1:44:57 And the slope?1:45:00 Uh, 5 to 1.1:45:01 5 to 1.1:45:02 Okay.1:45:04 All right, okay.1:45:06 We did the 2 foot of working depth to try to avoid— because it's a contractor yard, we're trying to avoid the fencing if possible.1:45:12 It's just going to get damaged.1:45:13 Mhm.1:45:14 Um, but that is— that was why we did what we did.1:45:16 Okay, that's fine.1:45:21 Okay, so we just need to, uh, review the stormwater, send it out, and we'll send it out.1:45:27 I have a question.1:45:28 Okay, now is there going to be any, um, retaining wall or anything?1:45:33 No, in the back near that?1:45:35 No, no, we were able to grade it in a manner that, uh, it didn't require any retaining walls.1:45:39 We always try to avoid them if we can, right?1:45:41 Uh, okay, all right, thank you.1:45:43 Of course.1:45:45 Any other questions from the board?1:45:50 Hearing none, any questions from the audience?1:45:57 Hearing none.1:45:57 Um, yeah, do you want to go to the 10th or you want to go to the— do it the 10th?1:46:03 Okay, I'll entertain a motion to continue to, uh, December 10th.1:46:07 So moved.1:46:08 Second.1:46:09 Motion made and seconded.1:46:10 All those in favor?1:46:11 Aye.1:46:11 Opposed?1:46:12 Motion carries unanimously.1:46:14 Thank you for coming.1:46:15 Thank you.1:46:15 Have a great night.1:46:16 Thank you.1:46:21 All right, which brings us to item 5 on the agenda, informational discussion with LEX Brook Crossing, Timothy Hasham and Marcus Baptiste.1:46:34 And Mr. O'Shaughnessy.1:46:35 Mr. Chairman.1:46:36 Oh, absolutely, use the chair.1:46:42 We used to have a, an eagle.1:46:45 Used to be an easel around here.1:46:46 I don't know where it went.1:46:47 Yeah, I'm gonna worry about it.1:46:50 Thank you.1:46:51 Microsoft 360 is down, so nobody's got nothing.1:46:56 I know, right?1:46:56 I have no idea.1:46:57 Still down.1:46:58 No, the world is in— nothing.1:47:00 It's down.1:47:03 Yeah, the other one came out awesome.1:47:07 Yep.1:47:08 All right, just— oh.1:47:11 Good evening, Mr. Chairman, all the members of the Board of Appeals.1:47:13 Michael O'Shaughnessy.1:47:14 I'm here today with Marcus Baptiste and Tim Hashem.1:47:18 I know you guys are familiar with this property.1:47:21 This was the former Oasis project site.1:47:25 Yep.1:47:26 What we would like to do is redevelop the property.1:47:31 Our parcel out here, out front, it's in the GU zone.1:47:37 The board of the town meeting approved the change to the zoning map the other night.1:47:41 They did, which is helpful.1:47:44 So what we'd like to discuss with you folks is to get some feedback on a potential residential property.1:47:54 This would be similar to the, the one, the tiny home project that Tim had built down in South Middleborough.1:48:01 You have pictures pictures there of the various styles of buildings that he did.1:48:07 What Tim and Marcus would like to do is to build 120 one-bedroom units up here and 40 here.1:48:20 The first floor of these 2 structures would be commercial or retail or whatever it is.1:48:27 What we're thinking at this time is half of this would be rental.1:48:34 The other half would be for sale.1:48:37 We would include an affordability component.1:48:40 So 25% on that side would be the for sale units would be affordable.1:48:46 And 25% of the rental units on this side, they might flip-flop whatever side it is, would be for rental.1:48:55 And these units— speaking my language— would be for rental as well.1:48:58 What's that?1:48:59 I said you're speaking my language.1:49:00 Yes, yes, yes.1:49:03 If we were to do this project, I'd like to do it— it would have to be through the variance process, similar to what we did in South Middleborough.1:49:11 As long as I can get my affordable numbers understood, I'm sure we— again, I'm sure we can come to an agreement.1:49:16 Variance standards have changed.1:49:17 There's been a softening of the statute.1:49:19 It's not as harsh as it was.1:49:22 It does include a provision for housing in there.1:49:26 Yeah, so we would come back to you folks requesting certain variances.1:49:30 I haven't analyzed it.1:49:31 I can't tell you what they are off the top of my head, but it'd be all for 1-bedroom units.1:49:38 It'd be similar in style to what Tim Dent down— all 1-bedroom, all 1-bedroom, all 1-bedroom.1:49:44 That's fine.1:49:44 We have some garages, garage bays at the end of the rows.1:49:49 Again, this is just a conceptual design.1:49:51 We just— piece of paper with some boxes on it right now.1:49:55 I've driven through the other project.1:49:57 That's come out quite nice, actually.1:49:59 Yeah, it is good.1:50:00 No, it did.1:50:01 So it'd be a local action unit.1:50:03 We'd do the agreement to restrict it.1:50:05 The town would be able to count them.1:50:07 Yep.1:50:07 And we would move forward.1:50:10 Well, the town's not looking for anything that's going to negatively impact our numbers.1:50:14 So again, 120 total.1:50:18 Uh, so there'd be— there's 60 on this side, Joe, 60 on this side, and there's 20— there's 40 in the front, 20 in each building.1:50:26 So 160 total.1:50:28 Okay, so it's 160.1:50:30 So 160 would be in the affordable?1:50:34 Uh, No, no, no, no.1:50:36 So rental units, they're all counted?1:50:39 Yeah, but you get 25%.1:50:40 It's only the affordable units counted.1:50:44 So for the 60, it'd be 15 would count, and on the rental side, they would all count.1:50:52 So wait a minute, I'm sorry, I got to back up.1:50:55 It's a total of 160.1:50:58 Total of 160.1:50:59 How many of the 160 60 are rentals?1:51:03 60?1:51:04 No, that'd be 100.1:51:05 100.1:51:06 Thank you.1:51:07 All right, so that's the numbers I'm looking for.1:51:09 Okay.1:51:09 Rentals.1:51:10 All right.1:51:10 Thank you.1:51:11 For sale.1:51:11 Okay.1:51:12 60 for sale.1:51:14 All right, so all 100 gets counted?1:51:19 Yes.1:51:20 Yep.1:51:21 What happens on the 60?1:51:22 15 with 15.1:51:24 15, you get— you only get the 25%.1:51:27 I see.1:51:28 Okay, so it'd be 115 overall.1:51:35 So would this be similar— you know, I'm going to ask about the handicap.1:51:38 Good evening, Tim Hashim, management partner of Lexbrook Crossing.1:51:44 Um, so I'll give you a little background on why we're involved in this project.1:51:47 So as you know, the board approved the 296 units that was there Um, previous developer did not move forward with that project, so I seen an opportunity to be able to get in there and do what I thought, you know, would be better suited for the property.1:52:06 Number one being commercial space.1:52:08 That's why we went to the town and got the GU zone extended.1:52:12 Number two, instead of 296 units of 1s, 2s, and 3s, go with 160 units of all one-bedrooms, which at that point there is no taxing on the school system at all.1:52:26 So, um, that's what we liked about it— tax base directly to the town.1:52:33 Nancy, to answer your question, yes, uh, I'm just going to throw this out there and you're probably going to just think about it.1:52:39 Yep.1:52:40 Um, part of the original project for the Oasis was a water loop.1:52:47 The water main we were connecting from Wareham back to basically looping through the property.1:52:52 Yep.1:52:52 Is that something we could do?1:52:55 We've talked to Mike Bumpus about that, and, um, I'm not sure where we left off with that.1:53:02 Marcus, do you know?1:53:04 So we don't— I'm not sure if it works for you, but I'm just We, you know, we— it's what we were trying to do the last time around.1:53:13 So I'm just— for the record, Marcus Baptiste, uh, we did speak with Mike about it.1:53:19 I believe to go out to Wareham would have to go under the wetlands or by our way out.1:53:27 I, I don't know that we can get out on our property.1:53:30 Okay, um, so we have to finish looking at that, but we did discuss that with Mike Bumpus.1:53:38 Okay.1:53:38 Are you accessing the same roadway that Oasis was going to access?1:53:42 No, I think you're further over.1:53:43 I think it's different.1:53:44 Is it?1:53:44 It's— well, yeah, it's further for— it's kind of right across from, uh, Barbados, I would say.1:53:51 Yeah, Nancy.1:53:51 Yeah, yeah, that's where I think it's further over because the original one had the, the commercial units were kind of twisted the other way, so I don't know.1:54:01 Correct.1:54:02 I'm thinking it was further down, just, just from memory.1:54:04 Yeah, and Darren, Marcus was right on that.1:54:06 We, we don't own— yeah, okay, with the water, that's what that would be, a reason you couldn't do it.1:54:12 Yeah.1:54:14 Um, so, you know, the idea on the front units where there's going to be 20 units in each building, I picture 3-story buildings, um, you know, a nice look to the buildings and commercial, call it retail or whatever, on the first floor would be what that would be.1:54:28 So how many square feet of commercial?1:54:35 Um, I don't know that footprint, sorry.1:54:36 Okay, whatever the footprint of the building would be, the whole first floor would be commercial, Joe.1:54:41 Of both of those?1:54:42 Correct.1:54:42 Yeah, if it says it, I can't see it.1:54:44 It's just information.1:54:45 Yeah, I think it's 7,000 or 8,000 footprint each building.1:54:52 But, you know, like Mashpee Common has the, you know, the mixed-use living.1:54:56 Yep.1:54:57 So that's kind of where we got that idea.1:54:59 Got the idea.1:55:00 Cool.1:55:01 So you would be purchasing Lot A?1:55:11 We'd be purchasing the lot that the, um, the homes are on.1:55:16 That would be the first First purchase.1:55:20 Second, sorry, first purchase was on Wareham Street.1:55:25 That's— so I see Lot A.1:55:27 That's Lot B.1:55:28 The 20 homes are going to be on Lot B. Yeah, because I don't own Lot A. I think so.1:55:37 Am I— where the hell's B?1:55:39 Right here to the left.1:55:40 C, right to the left.1:55:41 It's in there somewhere.1:55:43 All right.1:55:43 So this killing us with the— our eyes.1:55:46 So A, B, C, C's way up there.1:55:49 Is C all of the back section?1:55:53 So that looks like, guys, that looks like that is Lot C is off to the left.1:55:57 Yeah.1:55:58 Lot D would be the homes on the right.1:56:02 So the reason for that would be is the for-sale homes would be on its own lot.1:56:08 Mhm.1:56:08 The rental homes would be on be on its own lot, and the front commercial buildings would be on their own lot as the road would come in.1:56:14 All right, so you're deliberately coming in.1:56:18 Are you, are you acquiring Lot A?1:56:21 Lot A is the commercial, yes.1:56:23 All right, so, all right, that is further down the road.1:56:26 There's environmental impact there.1:56:27 This is, this is one of the keys to get to the environmental impact.1:56:32 You're bypassing in the cleanup, correct?1:56:34 Okay, got it.1:56:36 Yeah, and that's where we just had the zoning change, which is all GU now.1:56:40 Okay.1:56:41 Do you have an idea of the distance between these units and the properties on Cherry Street?1:56:52 Cherry Street?1:56:53 Yeah, we were— we know the elevation is high, but yeah, we were— we wanted to leave it— we were leaving a tree buffer.1:56:59 It was very important to us to keep a tree buffer, and I think we're around 80 feet of a tree buffer.1:57:03 Okay, don't quote me on that there.1:57:05 No, I just— the septic systems might— trying to get an idea because, yeah, the septic systems might be going behind the garages, and at that point, you know, there's not going to be no houses there.1:57:15 The houses— the units will be all of that, but the tree buffer is important for them and us.1:57:25 Yeah, would be nice to the loop in though.1:57:33 Yes.1:57:33 Um, so we just wanted to come to see, you know, if you, you guys seen our vision and understood it and wanted to go that next step to go to the drawing board, come back in 2 weeks.1:57:50 Just kidding.1:57:51 2 weeks, please.1:57:53 Ambitious.1:57:54 I know.1:57:55 I have a little question because I had gone to the Oasis meeting, you know, like to a few of them with ConCom.1:58:05 I know that they were gonna do like turtle sweeps and stuff in that area because there are— even though it's not on the map, there are box turtles in there.1:58:16 So the only thing I want to say, because I'm not ConCom come is just try to have a plan for that because there are a lot of eastern box turtles on that property.1:58:27 But yeah, it's just something to think about before you go to the next step.1:58:34 Yeah, of course.1:58:36 And Trish has all the information on that, so yes, at least that will help you because it's already been done.1:58:41 They've got to go there anyway.1:58:42 Yeah.1:58:44 But I like my job.1:58:48 I agree.1:58:52 And the apartments are nice.1:58:54 I mean, I've been in it.1:58:56 You know, I've been in them.1:58:56 They're beautiful.1:58:58 Yeah.1:58:58 And the other idea, guys, was, you know, to at least to have that for sale aspect also.1:59:04 So, you know, especially nowadays.1:59:08 Correct.1:59:09 Correct.1:59:10 So that would be nice.1:59:11 Well, it's a nice way for somebody to get started down to Lex Court where it's, it's mid-20s to mid-30s.1:59:18 And actually some of the single levels we've been— some of the older generation was our goal on that.1:59:24 And they went in.1:59:26 Yeah, we have a few that just moved in.1:59:29 So what type of commercial are you trying to attract down there?1:59:35 We would love retail.1:59:37 I mean, would love anything that would come and be a benefit to the town.1:59:40 Yeah, that would be great.1:59:43 But, you know, nothing at this point.1:59:46 But that would, you know, the idea is to keep that.1:59:50 They will have a customer base for sure.1:59:53 Exactly.1:59:54 Yeah.1:59:54 So that's why the thing— what you put there, the front buildings, you know, we're proposing the commercial in there also.2:00:00 So that's Stock commercial, little mix there, and whatever we can find to come to town.2:00:06 Maybe we can buy socks in town someday.2:00:09 There you go, right?2:00:09 Yeah, you can't.2:00:11 That's for Lot A.2:00:14 Yes.2:00:15 All right.2:00:17 Well, I, I like the concept.2:00:21 Thank you.2:00:22 Get the affordable numbers.2:00:23 I like it better.2:00:28 I don't know what anybody else thinks.2:00:33 I think it's a great concept as well.2:00:36 Like I said, it's an informational meeting, so yeah, we're going to take a vote on anything.2:00:40 So nope, no, we just wanted to get guidance and, you know, just to make sure that we're all on the same page.2:00:45 No, I appreciate the, uh, the heads up and coming before us.2:00:49 Yeah.2:00:50 Um, Anybody have a question?2:00:57 No?2:00:59 Fair enough.2:01:00 Well, thank you for coming.2:01:01 All right, thanks guys.2:01:02 Thank you.2:01:02 Thank you.2:01:03 Thank you.2:01:03 All right, you as well.2:01:05 I think it's downpouring out there, so I couldn't tell if that was like— yeah, no, it is rain.2:01:09 I think it's raining.2:01:10 No, we just looked up the radar.2:01:12 Really?2:01:12 Yeah, it's raining.2:01:13 It's flooding.2:01:14 We might, uh, we might miss it though.2:01:16 Have a good night.2:01:17 Thank you.2:01:18 Thank you.2:01:18 Thank you.2:01:19 Okay, um, good night.2:01:22 We have any other business before us?2:01:24 I do not believe we do.2:01:26 I will entertain a motion to adjourn.2:01:28 So moved.2:01:29 Second.2:01:30 Motion made and seconded.2:01:31 All those in favor?2:01:32 Aye.2:01:32 Aye.2:01:33 We are adjourned.2:01:33 Thank you all for coming.2:01:35 Thank you.
Spotted a mistake? and we’ll check it against the source.